Blog - California Custom Cellars

How Many Bottles of Wine Should I Have Initially vs. Leave Space for Growth?

Written by Founder | Nov 20, 2025 2:56:49 AM

Designing a wine cellar is an exciting step — but before you choose racking, layout, or display features, one key question comes up for almost every homeowner:

How many bottles should I start with, and how much room should I leave for future growth?

Whether you’re building your first wine cellar or upgrading an existing one, planning your bottle capacity wisely can ensure your cellar serves you beautifully today and adapts to your evolving collection.

Here’s how to strike the perfect balance.

Start by Assessing Your Current Collection

Your starting point is what you already own — but the number of bottles you have today is rarely the number you’ll have a year from now. Most collectors, even beginners, grow their collections faster than expected.

Ask yourself:

  • How many bottles do I currently store?

  • Do I buy wine in singles, 3-packs, or full cases?

  • Do I purchase wine regularly (monthly/quarterly) or only occasionally?

  • Do I collect by the case for aging purposes?

A common pattern among new cellar owners is underestimating growth. A modest 100–150 bottle collection can easily expand to 300+ once you begin buying wine with aging potential — or when you’re inspired by a beautifully designed cellar that invites collecting.

Understand Your Collecting Style

Your collecting habits significantly influence how much capacity you’ll need. Here are three common collector profiles:

1. The Everyday Drinker (50–200 bottles)

You enjoy wine regularly and want quick, convenient access to a variety of bottles. You may not age many wines long-term.

Recommended cellar size:
Start with capacity for 150–250 bottles to accommodate both daily drinking wines and some special bottles.

2. The Enthusiast (250–750 bottles)

You buy wine from a range of regions, attend tastings, and follow release schedules. You enjoy watching wines evolve over time.

Recommended cellar size:
Plan for 300–750 bottles, depending on purchasing habits and long-term plans.

3. The Collector/Investor (750+ bottles)

You buy in larger quantities, age wine for many years, and may store multiple vintages of the same wine.

Recommended cellar size:
A cellar with 800–2,000+ bottle capacity is typical, often with a mix of long-term storage and display elements.

The 60/40 Rule: Your Best Planning Strategy

When designing a cellar, a reliable guideline is the 60/40 Rule:

  • 60% of your capacity should be dedicated to long-term storage

  • 40% should be open or flexible for new additions, rotating inventory, and display

For example:
A 500-bottle cellar should have roughly 200 bottles of space available for new wines over time.

This prevents overcrowding — which reduces airflow and makes bottles hard to access — and ensures your cellar ages gracefully with your collection.

Leave Room for Growth (More Than You Think)

Most homeowners expand their wine habits once they have a dedicated cellar. It’s common to see collections double within 2–5 years — especially among Newport Beach homeowners who:

  • Join wine clubs

  • Travel to wine regions

  • Host dinners and tastings

  • Start buying wines by the case

A good rule of thumb:
Plan for 2–3 times your current collection size.

If you have 150 bottles now, design a cellar that holds 350–500 bottles.
If you have around 300 bottles, plan closer to 700–1,000.

You’ll never regret extra space — but you will outgrow a too-small cellar quickly.

Consider Your Mix of Bottles

Not all racks work for all bottle types. When calculating capacity, keep in mind:

  • Champagne and sparkling wines need wider racks

  • Magnums and large-format bottles need specialty storage

  • Display bottles may need label-forward space

  • Case storage requires bulk bins or deep shelving

A well-designed cellar blends several rack styles to accommodate all shapes and sizes without wasting space.

Plan for Future Display Features

If you want your cellar to evolve aesthetically, leave room for:

  • Decorative niches

  • Feature walls

  • Floating bottle displays

  • Backlit shelves

  • Magnum or champagne displays

This ensures your cellar remains a showpiece as your collection matures.

Final Thoughts

Deciding how many bottles to start with — and how much space to allow for growth — is one of the most important steps in designing a wine cellar that evolves with you. A thoughtful layout ensures your collection remains organized, accessible, and beautifully displayed for years to come.